Thirty-3 years earlier, Soviet dissident Yuli Edelstein was arrested by the KGB and also sent out to the gulag for committing the “crime” of being a spiritual Jew and also a Hebrew teacher. Last week, Edlestein, now the speaker of the Israeli Knesset, addressed the Russian parliament in Hebrew.

You are watching: Friendship united methodist church north korea

It was a memorable reminder of the complimentary world’s victory over Communism. And its timing was apt. Edelstein took the Israeli push on a brief tour of his life as a refusenik, and ultimately we uncovered ourselves in the courtroom in which Edelstein was convicted and sentenced.

I couldn’t aid however notification the important lessons Edelstein’s story holds for those trying to make sense of another totalitarian prisoner whose fate was a lot more tragic: Otto Warmbier, the American male sentenced in North Korea in 2016 to 15 years of tough labor under the pretense that he stole a poster. He was released while in a coma last month, and passed away days after getting to the United States.

And for some factor, many kind of commenting on the case are taking at confront worth the North Korean government’s version of events. Prisoners of totalitarian regimes, like Yuli Edelstein, can display them the folly of such credulity.

Edelstein was arrested on trumped-up drug charges. The police searched his apartment and also planted a matchbox filled via marijuana and also opium. They asserted it was the matchbox he had offered to light Shabbat candles. As Edelstein’s defense attorney stated, the woguy of the home lights candles at the begin of the Sabbath, not the male.

The government’s witnesses told incontinuous stories. One neighbor shelp the Edelsteins lived far beyond the suggests that were normal in the Soviet Union. But when tright here was a follow-up question asking her to provide examples, she couldn’t — no one had offered her that answer in breakthrough, and the premise was false.

In the end, although the court sassist tbelow was insufficient evidence to prove illegal drug usage, Edelstein was sentenced to three years’ tough labor.

As I check out and also listened to the details of the present trial, I was reminded of the truth that a bizarre number of steady commentators seem to think Warmbier had actually it coming, and that his “white privilege” led him to think he can steal.


A professor at the College of Delaware sassist Warmbier “acquired precisely what he deserved” as a “young, white, affluent, cluemuch less white” guy and a “spoiled, naive, arrogant US college student that never had actually to challenge the results of his actions.”

She was fired, but she’s far from the only one to make these kinds of statements. Salon publiburned an article calling Warmbier “America’s biggest idiot frat boy,” which it rerelocated after his death.

Yet once subjected to the slightest scrutiny, Pyongyang’s story starts to fall acomponent.

In Warmbier’s required confession, he said he was ordered to steal the poster by the Friendship United Methodist Church in Wyoming, Ohio.

The trouble through that story? Warmbier was Jewish. He was even energetic in his campus Hillel and also had gone on a Birthright Israel trip. His parental fees hid his Jewishness from the public while negotiations for his release were under method.

In North Korea, favor in the Soviet Union, there’s no such point as a fair trial or justice. It’s an evil regime, and also buying their side of the story only empowers them.

When Edelstein and also other refuseniks were imprisoned, human being about the civilization rallied around the reason of releasing them and also fighting the injustice, because they kbrand-new whom they were managing. They knew the USSR couldn’t be trusted.

Ultimately, the overwhelming push from the complimentary human being functioned, and also Edelstein was released to Israel, wright here, over the past 30 years, he functioned his method to the third-highest political office in the state.

See more: Lyrics For Down By The Water Down By The Old Main Drag, The Decemberists

It’s also late to conserve Otto Warmbier, yet there are many kind of, many kind of others imprisoned in North Korean labor camps. May those of us enjoying the freedoms and privileges of democracy learn from Yuli Edelstein’s story, and also execute our part to set them complimentary.